Monday, January 6, 2020
Outline and Evaluate Milgramââ¬â¢s Concept of ââ¬ÅAgentic Shiftââ¬Â.
Outline and Evaluate Milgramââ¬â¢s concept of ââ¬Å"agentic shiftâ⬠. Following results of his world famous obedience studies, Milgram developed his own theory of why people obey a malevolent authority ââ¬â ââ¬Å"agentic shiftâ⬠. Milgram findings led him to believe a person can be in one of two psychological state at any particular time, and the ââ¬Å"agentic shiftâ⬠is what causes ordinary people to follow orders because they believed the experimenter has a legitimate authority. Milgram believed people acted without thinking, irrespective of their own beliefs - the participants were obliged to do as the experimenter said because of the experimenters ââ¬Å"authorityâ⬠. However other researchers such as Blass (1999) and Reicher and Haslam (2011) broadened the outlookâ⬠¦show more contentâ⬠¦(An expert). Blass (1999) enabled the understanding we had on Milgramââ¬â¢s notion of agentic shift to broaden, providing us with a different perspective on Milgram findings. Milgram (2004 [1974] cited Dickerson, 2012:373) himself sugge sted that both expertise and authority are important, ââ¬Ëbecause the experimenter issues orders in a context he is presumed to know something about, his power increasesââ¬â¢. Furthermore, can Blass (1999) change our perspective on ââ¬Ëagentic shiftââ¬â¢, presuming ââ¬Ëagentic shiftââ¬â¢ is still considered the most efficient way of explain Milgramââ¬â¢s findings then could expertise be the reason for the ââ¬Ëagentic shiftââ¬â¢ rather than authority. In addition to this critical review of the Milgram study, Blass (1999) addressed the conformity levels during the time of the experiment, Blass (1999) suggested that Milgramââ¬â¢s high levels of obedience were a symptom of the time and culture in which the studies were carried out, and in more recent years conformity has decreased, however there was no relationship found between the date of the study and level of conformity found. Although there are a number of findings that dictate the need for explanation obedience, Reicher and Haslam (2011) argued that rather than a form of ââ¬Ëagentic shiftââ¬â¢ occurring for the
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.